Water-based (hydronic) underfloor heating systems are generally considered to be more cost-effective to run in the long term compared to electric underfloor heating systems. Here’s why:

Water-Based (Hydronic) Underfloor Heating:

  • Energy Efficiency: Hydronic systems are typically more energy-efficient than electric systems. They operate at lower water temperatures and provide consistent warmth over a longer period, which can lead to lower energy consumption and operating costs.
  • Lower Operating Costs: Because of their energy efficiency, water-based systems tend to have lower operating costs over time compared to electric systems. This cost savings can be especially significant in larger areas where electric heating might consume more energy.
  • Heat Retention: Water retains heat longer than electric heating elements. Once the system reaches the desired temperature, it can maintain the warmth for an extended period, reducing the need for constant heating.
  • Integration with Efficient Heat Sources: Water-based systems can be integrated with energy-efficient heat sources such as heat pumps, solar thermal systems, or high-efficiency boilers. This further contributes to cost savings and reduced environmental impact.
  • Zoning: Hydronic systems can be divided into zones, allowing you to heat specific areas of your home based on your needs. This zoning capability helps avoid heating unoccupied spaces, leading to additional energy savings.

Electric Underfloor Heating:

  • Quick Heat-Up: Electric systems heat up faster than water-based systems. However, this rapid heat-up comes at the cost of higher energy consumption.
  • Smaller Areas: Electric underfloor heating might be more cost-effective for smaller areas or spaces where the heating demand is lower.
  • Individual Room Control: Electric systems often offer individual room control through separate thermostats, allowing you to heat only the areas you’re using. This can help manage energy usage.

While water-based underfloor heating tends to be more cost-effective over the long term, it’s important to note that upfront installation costs for water-based systems can be higher due to the need for a heat source, pipes, and a manifold. Electric systems, on the other hand, have lower upfront costs but might result in higher operating costs over time.


Contact us